The Fed’s New Communications Playbook Is Already Being Tested
Diccon HyattThu, September 3, 2026 at 11:23 PM GMT+3 4 min read
Credit: David Paul Morris / Bloomberg via Getty Images
Key Takeaways
-
Fed Governor Christopher Waller said it was valuable for Fed officials to explain how they would react to upcoming economic data and what would prompt them to adjust the central bank's key interest rate,
-
That's in direct contrast to Fed Chair Kevin Warsh, who has criticized such communications.
-
Waller said he would favor raising interest rates in September only if an upcoming report shows inflation running unexpectedly high.
Leaders at the Federal Reserve are debating how the central bank communicates with the public, and the outcome of their dispute could change the whole ball game for financial markets.
On Thursday, Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller defended the practice of explaining to the public what he thinks the Fed should do with interest rates if future economic data comes in a certain way. Such conditional statements were a staple of Fed communications under former chair Jerome Powell and some of his predecessors.
However, Fed Chair Kevin Warsh has avoided making them since taking office in May, and has repeatedly criticized the practice.
The Fed's communication policy determines how much information the public receives about the Fed's thoughts on the economy. At any given meeting of the Fed's policy committee, officials could vote to raise the benchmark fed funds rate to push up borrowing costs throughout the economy and dampen inflation; lower it to encourage spending and boost the job market; or hold it steady.
Currently, policymakers are deciding whether to raise interest rates to push down inflation, which is still running above the Fed's 2% annual target for a fifth year. Some "hawks" on the FOMC have spoken out in favor of a rate hike, while others have advocated a wait-and-see approach.
What This Means For The Economy
Financial markets could get less information about the Fed's forthcoming moves if Kevin Warsh follows through on his criticism of the Fed's communication to the public. That would add more uncertainty to all kinds of economic forecasts.
Waller, who is considered by experts a swing voter between those two groups, explained his own "reaction function" Thursday in a speech at an event with Reuters. He made it clear that his vote at the next meeting hinged on the forthcoming report on the Consumer Price Index inflation gauge for August.
"If there is continued progress toward our 2% goal, then I am willing to support holding the policy rate at its current level," Waller said. "But if inflation comes in hot, I would consider a rate hike."
Financial markets slashed their bets on a Fed rate hike in response to the comments, and stock prices rose as the chances of higher borrowing costs down the road diminished.
As of Thursday afternoon, it was down to a coin flip whether the Fed would raise rates at its next meeting, down from a 63% chance the day before, according to the CME Group's FedWatch tool, which forecasts rate movements based on fed funds futures trading data.
That's just the kind of interaction Warsh said he wants to snuff out.
Warsh believes that signals from the Fed about its upcoming moves distort financial markets and can limit the Fed's flexibility in responding to economic changes. That's why he has moved to curtail "reaction function" statements, as well as their stronger cousin, "forward guidance," in which Fed officials unambiguously state their plans for rate movements.
At a press conference in July, Warsh said markets should "play the ball, not the referee," meaning reacting to economic data rather than what they expect the Fed to do.
"Many of you might be interested in our reaction function—we're interested in the reaction of financial markets," he said at a press conference in July. And later, at a landmark speech at the Jackson Hole conference, Warsh dissed reaction function statements once more.
Waller turned Warsh's analogy around Thursday, comparing the Fed to a home plate umpire calling balls and strikes. Stating a reaction function, he said, is like declaring a strike zone.
"The players don't expect the umpire to have a perfect strike zone—they just need a rough idea of its parameters and some guarantee that it won't change much on every pitch," he said.
Although Waller said he agreed with Warsh that it was inappropriate for the Fed to offer forward guidance in normal times, his philosophy on communication differs from that of the new Fed boss. Some experts saw Waller's speech as a version of the "good family fight" that Warsh said he wants policymakers to have under his leadership.
"Gonna take a wild guess that Umpire Waller might not be Warsh's fav version of Waller," economist Claudia Sahm posted on the X social media platform.
Sahm, however, called foul on both central bankers, saying neither Warsh's ref nor Waller's umpire is a good analogy for what the Fed does.
"The Fed isn't calling balls and strikes; it's MAKING the play," she wrote. "The Fed is LeBron, not the ref."
Read the original article on Investopedia
Yorumlar (0)
Giriş yaparak yorum yazabilirsin.
İlk yorumu sen yaz.